Alastair Hay BSc (Hons) LCH RSHom | M: 07940 525495 | E: al@homeopathical.com
HomeopathicAl
  • About
  • Consultations
  • Workshops
  • News

"Why did my GP prescribe antibiotics for my child’s tonsillitis when they deduced it's most likely to be a viral infection?"

10/7/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
This was a question I was asked earlier this week during a homeopathic consultation.

As serendipity would have it, an article printed on the same day as the consultation pretty much concluded what answer I gave to the parents. More oddly still, the chief investigator of the programme is Alastair Hay! It’s not me though, he’s the Professor of Primary care at The University of Bristol as well as a GP.

The answer I gave, was that we tend to go to the GP because we want reassurance that everything is OK, or that something is going on that’s beyond what we’re able to deal with ourselves. The GP then feels a duty to reassure, and often prescribe.

We live in an ever increasingly litigious society so the GP may also feel pressurised to prescribe something ‘just in case’. Imagine a situation where a GP hadn’t prescribed a medicine, yet could have done, and something more serious precipitated that was deemed preventable with early intervention with antibiotics.

We can also feel that we’ve wasted our GPs time if they don’t prescribe.

There’s also an increasing trend toward parents being considered negligent if they don’t seek medical advice, our GP often being the most reliable, first port of call.

Conclusions in this article which I wholeheartedly agree with are:

Dr Cabral and her colleagues believe that interventions to reduce unnecessary prescribing for children with respiratory tract infections (RTIs) should increase GPs’, and to a lesser extent parents’, confidence in the safety of not prescribing. This will allow them to modify their behaviour while still conforming to the social norm of ensuring child safety.

Dr Cabral added: “We also need to increase parents’ confidence in their ability to distinguish and care for self-limiting illness at home.  An increasing number of children are attending primary care or A&E and health services are struggling to cope. Our research shows that simple messages such as telling parents to manage these illness at home are unlikely to work when there is such a social pressure on parents to consult. We need to engage more widely with the social beliefs that create that pressure on parents.”

Further reading:

“It's safer to …” parent consulting and clinician antibiotic prescribing decisions for children with respiratory tract infections: An analysis across four qualitative studies

Why are so many children given antibiotics for a cough?

NHS sets aside quarter of its budget for medical negligence claims
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    News and Blog, directly from Al to you.
    WARNING: I CAN BE CONTROVERSIAL ON HERE

    RSS Feed

    The most current news articles I uncover can be found on my Twitter page

    Tweets by @homeopathical

    Archives

    April 2021
    October 2019
    September 2019
    July 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    March 2018
    July 2015
    June 2014
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013

    Categories

    All
    Agenda
    Alastair Hay
    Allergy
    Antibiotics
    Antihistamines
    Bachelor Of Science Homeopathy
    Ban Homeopathy
    Chinese Water-snake
    Con
    Deluded
    Deluded Fool
    Evidence
    GP
    Grass Pollen
    Hay Fever
    Homeopathical
    Homeopathic Medicine
    Homeopathy
    Homeopathy Bsc
    Homeopathy Is Dangerous
    Homeopathy Is Placebo
    Homeopathy Is Witchcraft
    Immunity
    Medicine
    NHS
    NHS Homeopathy
    Pharmacology
    Piriton
    Placebo
    Placebo Effect
    Pollen
    Pollen Calender
    Proving
    Pseudosceptic
    Pseudoskeptic
    Pseudo Skeptic
    Rct
    Rcts
    Rhinitis
    Sceptic
    Scepticism
    Sceptics Agenda
    Science
    Scientific
    Sham
    Skeptic
    Skepticism
    Skeptics Agenda
    Snake Oil
    Snake-oil
    Snake Oil Salespeople
    Snake Oil Sales People
    Tonsillitis
    Witchcraft


    www.homeopathical.com copyright © Alastair Hay
    BSc (Hons) LCH RSHom Homoeopath

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.